| Season | League | Regular Season Finish | Finals Series | Dockerty Cup | Other | |
| 2010 | Victorian Premier League | 6th (12 teams) |
Missed finals | – | Singapore Cup Quarter Final (4-6 agg v Bangkok Glass) |
|
| 2011 | Victorian Premier League | 4th (13 teams) |
Semi Final (0-1 v Oakleigh) |
Fifth Round (1-2 v Port Melbourne) |
Singapore Cup First Round (0-3 v Albirex) |
|
| 2012 | Victorian Premier League | 6th (12 teams) |
Missed finals | Fifth Round (1-2 v Port Melbourne) |
||
| 2013 | Victorian Premier League | 4th (12 teams) |
Prelim Final (0-5 v Northcote) |
Semi Final (0-1 v Green Gully) |
||
| Season | League | Regular Season Finish | Finals Series | Dockerty Cup | FFA Cup | Other |
| 2014 | NPL Victoria | Premiers (14 teams) |
NPL Victoria: Champions (First past the post) National Series: Semi Final (1-2 v MetroStars) |
Quarter Final (0-2 v Melbourne Knights) |
Did not qualify | – |
| 2015 | NPL Victoria | Premiers (14 teams) |
NPL Victoria: Grand Finalist (1-3 aet v Bentleigh Greens) National Series: Quarter Final (0-1 v Hobart Olympia) |
Champions (3-0 v Oakleigh Cannons) |
Round of 32 (1-1 [7-8p] v Palm Beach) |
Charity Shield Winners (2-1 v Melbourne Knights) |
| 2016 | NPL Victoria | 3rd (14 teams) |
Champions (3-2 v Oakleigh Cannons) |
Quarter Final (0-4 v Bentleigh Greens) |
Did not qualify | Charity Shield Finalist (0-3 v Bentleigh) |
| 2017 | NPL Victoria | 2nd (14 teams) |
Semi Final (2-2 [3-5p] v Bentleigh Greens) |
Semi Final (0-2 v Bentleigh Greens) |
Semi Final (1-5 v Sydney FC) |
Charity Shield Finalist (1-2 v Bentleigh) |
| 2018 | NPL Victoria | 10th (14 teams) |
Missed finals | Fourth Round (0-1 v Hume City) |
Did not qualify | – |
| 2019 | NPL Victoria | 8th (14 teams) |
Missed finals | Quarter Final (2-4 v Melbourne Knights) |
Did not qualify | – |