National Soccer League
Player of the Year (Johnny Warren Medal)
- 1986 – Bobby Russell
- 1988 – Paul Wade
- 1993 – Paul Trimboli
- 1998 – Paul Trimboli
Player of the Grand Final (Joe Marston Medal)
- 1998 – Fausto De Amicis
- 1999 – Goran Lozanovski
Leading Goal Scorer
- 1983 – Doug Brown (16 goals)
- 1984 – Doug Brown (22 goals)
- 1985 – Charlie Egan (21 goals)
- 1992 – Kimon Taliadoros (15 goals)
- 1993 – Francis Awaritefe (19 goals)
Goalkeeper of the Year
- 1999 – Michael Petkovic
- 2001 – Michael Petkovic
- 2002 – Michael Petkovic
Coach of the Year
- 1980 – John Margaritis
- 1988 – Brian Garvey
- 1993 – Jim Pyrgolios
- 1998 – Ange Postecoglou
- 2001 – Michael Petersen
U21 Player of the Year (Sam Papasavas Award)
- 1983 – Oscar Crino
- 1988 – Paul Trimboli
- 1989 – Paul Trimboli
Victorian State League / Premier League / NPL Victoria
Player of the Year (Gold Medal)
- 2010 – Fernando De Moraes
- 2014 – Milos Lujic
- 2023 – Jake Marshall
Player of the Grand Final (Jimmy Rooney Medal)
- 2006 – Fernando De Moraes
- 2016 – Marcus Schroen
Player of the Dockerty Cup Final (Jim Mackay Medal)
- 2015 – Milos Lujic
- 2024 – Javi Lopez
Leading Goal Scorer (Regular Season)
- 1960 – Tony Hatzieleftheriou (50+ goals in Div 1)
- 1961 – Tony Hatzieleftheriou (16 goals)
- 1964 – Michael Mandalis (17 goals)
- 1965 – Ernie Ackerley (16 goals)
- 1966 – Con Nestoridis (21 goals)
- 1972 – Jim Armstrong (20 goals)
- 1974 – Jim Armstrong (22 goals)
- 2014 – Milos Lujic (22 goals)
- 2015 – Milos Lujic (21 goals)
- 2016 – Milos Lujic (25 goals)
- 2022 – Harrison Sawyer (17 goals)
- 2024 – Harrison Sawyer (16 goals)
Goalkeeper of the Year
- 2005 – Dean Anastasiadis
- 2006 – Dean Anastasiadis
- 2010 – Peter Zois
- 2013 – Peter Gavalas
- 2022 – Javi Lopez
- 2023 – Javi Lopez
- 2024 – Javi Lopez
Coach of the Year
- 2014 – Chris Taylor
- 2024 – Esteban Quintas
Players’ Player of the Year
- 2014 – Milos Lujic
- 2015 – Nick Epifano
Rising Star / Young Player of the Year (formerly Weinstein Medal)
- 1975 – Reno Lia
- 2016 – Matthew Millar
Media Player of the Year (Bill Fleming Award)
- 1971 – Jim Pyrgolios
- 1974 – Jim Armstrong
Goal of the Year
- 2024 – Mario Barcia